Uncrustables are super tasty, convenient sandwiches made by Smucker’s. They’re sold frozen, which keeps them safe to eat for longer than a traditional sandwich would be. But inevitably people end up asking: how long do Uncrustables take to thaw?
According to Smucker’s, Uncrustables should be thawed at room temperature for 30 to 60 minutes. Eat them within six to eight hours of thawing for optimal freshness.
Can Uncrustables be thawed in the microwave?
If you want your Uncrustables sandwich to thaw quicker than the recommended minimum of 30 minutes, you wouldn’t be alone in wondering if you can defrost it in the microwave. Don’t do it! Smucker’s is adamant that Uncrustables sandwiches should never be microwaved.
This is because the filling inside of the sandwich gets hotter more quickly than the bread on the outside. More often than not, you won’t know that the inside of your Uncrustables sandwich is hot enough to burn you since the outside still feels cold.
To be completely safe, Smucker’s recommends that you avoid ever attempting to thaw an Uncrustables sandwich in the microwave.
What methods are there to thaw Uncrustables fast?
Luckily, if you want to thaw Uncrustables fast, you have a few options:
- Use your own body heat by placing the sandwich between your hands and rubbing lightly
- Let it sit somewhere warm, like a window sill facing the sunlight
- Submerge the wrapped sandwich in a warm bowl of water
No matter how you thaw your Uncrustables sandwich, make sure to eat it as soon as possible!
Can you thaw Uncrustables in the fridge?
If you don’t want to eat your Uncrustables sandwich right away, you could choose to thaw it in the fridge instead. This method takes longer, but refrigerated Uncrustables can be kept for up to one day if thawed in the fridge instead of room temperature.
Can you get food poisoning from Uncrustables?
You can get food poisoning from any food that’s been left out for too long, and Uncrustables are no exception. According to the USDA, food should never be left out longer than two hours because the drop in temperature moves it into the Danger Zone.
The Danger Zone, between 40 and 140 degrees Fahrenheit, is where harmful bacteria thrive. As a general rule, remember to keep “hot food hot” and “cold food cold.” Once Uncrustables thaw out completely, eat them as soon as possible to avoid getting food poisoning.
In summary
Smucker’s Uncrustables are undoubtedly worth the 30-minute wait when it comes to thawing them out. But if you’re hungry right now and you want your Uncrustables quick, try using your body heat, placing it somewhere warm, or dipping the wrapped sandwich in warm water. These methods are fast, easy, and safer than sticking an Uncrustables sandwich in the microwave!
